Top 10 Car Dealerships in Long Island, NY
Noble Motorcars, Smith Haven Mazda, and Bright Bay Mazda lead the Google review race in Long Island, New York. If you operate a Long Island dealership, these are the stores you compete against every time a buyer in the metro runs a search.
Noble Motorcars
- Combined Google reviews
- 17,531
- Average rating
- 4.78★
- Reviews held by the leader
- 3,129
- Rated 4.8★ or higher
- 50%
The Long Island, NY Top 10
Data as of May 20, 2026- Rank1
Noble Motorcars
Independent1430 Church St, Bohemia, NY 11716
5.01,181 reviews·Score: 4.95 - Rank2
Smith Haven Mazda
Franchise827 NY-25, St James, NY 11780
4.93,129 reviews·Score: 4.88Mazda - Rank3
Bright Bay Mazda
Franchise1200 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
4.82,412 reviews·Score: 4.78Mazda - Rank4
Wantagh Mazda
Franchise3180 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh, NY 11793
4.8930 reviews·Score: 4.75Mazda - Rank5
Enterprise Car Sales
Used1141 E Jericho Tpke, Huntington, NY 11743
4.8654 reviews·Score: 4.73 - Rank6
Mercedes-Benz of Huntington
Franchise1103 E Jericho Tpke, Huntington, NY 11743
4.73,100 reviews·Score: 4.69Mercedes-Benz - Rank7
Mercedes-Benz of Massapequa
Franchise101 Sunrise Hwy, Amityville, NY 11701
4.72,650 reviews·Score: 4.69Mercedes-Benz - Rank8
Acura of Bay Shore
Franchise1930 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
4.72,110 reviews·Score: 4.68Acura - Rank9
Empire Volvo Cars Smithtown
Franchise633 Middle Country Rd, St James, NY 11780
4.7692 reviews·Score: 4.65Volvo - Rank10
Generation Buick GMC
Franchise4825-A Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd, Bohemia, NY 11716
4.7673 reviews·Score: 4.65BuickGMC
The Long Island dealership review landscape
Long Island is one of the most competitive new- and used-car markets in New York. If your store is outside the top 10, you are fighting against this review velocity for every "long island car dealer" search Google runs.
Reviews drive AI search visibility in New York
50% of the top 10 in Long Island already hold a 4.8-star rating or higher. In a market this dense, simply being "good" is no longer enough — you have to be measurably best to be cited by name when AI search engines answer questions about Long Island, New York.
Want to read more on closing the review gap? A3 Brands publishes a how A3 Brands approaches automotive SEO for dealership operators.
How the Long Island, NY ranking is calculated
Combines star rating with review volume so a small Long Island store with a few perfect reviews does not outrank a high-volume dealership, and a mega-store with thousands of mediocre reviews does not outrank a smaller, consistently excellent one.
New York dealerships with fewer than 25 Google reviews, and listings outside the Long Island metro trading area. We use the dealer-density centroid of each metro — not city limits — so dealerships in surrounding New York suburbs that compete for Long Island buyers are included. Insurance agencies, repair shops, and auto-service businesses miscategorized as car dealers are filtered out by name and category.
Pulled from Google Business Profile via the DataForSEO Business Listings API. The snapshot above was captured on 2026-05-20 and is refreshed quarterly. Verify live numbers on each store's Google profile before making decisions on this data.
Three reasons that might be: your dealership has fewer than 25 Google reviews, sits outside the Long Island metro radius we searched, or its Bayesian-weighted score didn't crack the top 10. None of these reflect on the dealership itself — review velocity is one signal among many, and closing the gap to the top 10 is exactly the work A3 Brands does for New York dealerships.
Disclosure: This data is sourced from each dealership's public Google Business Profile, accessed via the DataForSEO Business Listings API under license. Dealerships shown here have not been contacted, paid, or sponsored — inclusion is based entirely on public review data, not on any business relationship with A3 Brands. To request a correction, flag a data error, or have your dealership reviewed for removal, email info@a3brands.com.
About the Long Island dealership ranking
The top three dealerships in Long Island, New York by Bayesian-weighted Google review score are Noble Motorcars, Smith Haven Mazda, and Bright Bay Mazda. The full top 10 — and the review counts you would have to match to enter that list — is ranked above.
Each Long Island, NY dealership receives a Bayesian-weighted score that combines its Google star rating and review volume. The formula is (reviews × rating + 100 × 4.3) / (reviews + 100), where 4.3 is the global average star rating across car dealerships. This balances small high-rated stores against large high-volume ones.
Google ranks dealerships in the local pack and Google Maps results using review count and rating as primary signals. AI search engines — Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini — increasingly cite the highest-rated stores by name when answering questions about Long Island, New York. If your dealership is not on this list, you are not in the conversation buyers in Long Island are having.
Quarterly. Star ratings and review counts shift slowly, so a quarterly refresh keeps the list current without churn from week-to-week noise. The data above was last refreshed 2026-05-20.
A3 Brands is an automotive SEO agency that works with dealerships across the United States, including New York. This ranking is based purely on public Google review data — no dealership pays to be included or excluded, and no editorial weighting is applied.
Most New York dealerships are not in the top 10 — by definition, only 10 stores per metro can be. If your dealership is not ranked, it is for one of three reasons: it has fewer than 25 Google reviews, it sits outside the Long Island metro radius, or its Bayesian-weighted score did not place in the top 10 against the local competition. None of these are signals that your store is underperforming overall — review velocity is one signal among many, and closing the gap to the Long Island top 10 is exactly the work A3 Brands does for New York dealership clients. The database refreshes quarterly, so stores can move into and out of the top 10 between snapshots as review velocity changes.
A Long Island dealership can be missing for three reasons: it has fewer than 25 Google reviews, it sits outside the Long Island metro trading area we searched, or its Bayesian-weighted score did not place in the top 10 against the competition. Note that the Long Island list reflects the metro trading area — dealerships in surrounding New York suburbs that compete for Long Island buyers are included, while listings far outside the metro are excluded even if they technically share a postal city or state.
Want to outrank Noble Motorcars?
The free Competitor DNA Report shows you where your store ranks against the Long Island, NY competitors above — review-velocity gap, AI search citation share, and a 30-day plan tailored to your market.